opening it up with Common Lisp |
||
Favorite weblogs Lisp Related Politics Other home Recent Readings
Book review: Darwinia
Summer reading: Spin
Runner
the Omnivoire's Delimma
the Golem's Eye |
On the Robustness of Centrality Measures under Conditions of Imperfect Data Everyone is familiar with how polling (or sampling) can be used to estimate values for entire populations while examining only a tiny fraction of its members. This works very well (2000 and 2004 elections not withstanding) when the values in question are independent of the relationships among the members of the population. That is, we can estimate the average height of all 26-year olds by measuring only a few of them because the height of each 26-old is assumed to be independent of all others. The problem is that when the values we care about are relationships, sampling is no longer so easy. We can draw valid conclusions from samples of a population if and only if we have independence between each sample member but when we have relationships (graphs), independence is out the door (if for no other reason than that most real world graphs have friend of a friend structure: it's more likely that you my friends will know each other than not). To pursue this, Borgatti, Carley and Krackhardt investigate one typical graph measure under varying noise conditions to see how the noise alters the sampling results. This is definitely useful and important research - not to mention a paper that practically writes itself! - and the authors do a good job explaining their methodology and results. The only serious limitation of their work is that they study only Erdos / Renyi random graphs (see here for a summary of Marc Newman's excellent SIAM survey on graph theoyr) and only random noise. As they themselves conclude:
Erdos / Renyi random graphs are easy to analyze but by now everyone knows (yes, even your two year old) that they are very poor models for real networks - the ones we care about. If I have time, I'd like to follow up their results. |
Home | About | Quotes | Recent | Archives Copyright -- Gary Warren King, 2004 - 2006 |